Hey everybody,
In an effort of processing my experiences here in Guatemala, I thought I share some of the things I have learned here so far. As you know, I have been interviewing NGOs here on a variety of themes, such as their strategies, their effectiveness, etc. In addition, I have had talks with members of social movements, local NGOs, and people in government. My personal insights so far can be summarized as follows:
- Development is a messy field. The field is incredibly fragmented with hundreds of organizations, movements, and initiatives trying to improve the situation in Guatemala somehow. Community-based organizations, social movements, Southern NGOs, Northern NGOs, bilateral development agencies, such as US AID, multilateral development organizations, such as Worldbank, UNDP work on such diverse topics as, health, education, environmental protection, economic development, human rights, etc. Each of this organization has its own objectives, its own strategy (which of course is superior to all the others). There is almost no coordination of efforts, nor an exchange of best practices or successful methodologies. And funny enough, every single person I talked to is aware of it
- Development is a confusing field. Many development indicators in Guatemala are continuing to worsen despite of the high influx of development funds and the fact that many of development organizations have been working here for over 40 years. Even the most straight forward indicators that are supposedly easier to improve, such as child mortality, are still horrendous. Almost 50% of all children in Guatemala between 1 and 5 are malnourished. When asking how this can be, I got two types of answers. Either the NGOs admitted that their strategies in the past have been large part ineffective or they said that it is the other organizations that are working in a paternalistic, non-sustainable way, thereby creating dependencies and not really improving the situation. Or it is the government that is lacking support for their activities and projects. The strategies I have been presented with were all very convincing, centering around a rights-based approach to development, empowering communities, and building capacity on a local level. Yet, there seems to be a discrepancy between what people seem to advocate and what the reality of this country and development efforts displays
- Development is a highly ideological field. This is probably what has frustrated me the most since I am here. All the finger pointing, the blaming, the accusations either geared towards the government, other NGOs (see above), but also towards multilateral and bilateral agencies and Northern NGOs. Not to forget the private sector, the arch enemy of many development activists (the fact that some U.S. NGOs are collaborating with WalMart on projects does not help their credibility with the activists). What is so frustrating is not the validity of criticism but that the effectiveness or success of development efforts is sacrificed for idealogical reasons. Complex systems are simplified, possible partners are demonized, the range of ideas and possible cooperations are diminished, no matter how fruitful these efforts could be. It's an economization of thought that takes place when I listen to another night of platitudes by certain activists bashing every initiative that is not in line with their own political ideology. And while I understand how Guatemalan civil society organizations are skeptical of its own government due to the conflictive history of this country, I do not comprehend how there is not more cooperation and interaction between non-governmental development organizations, how this climate of competition and hostility can prevail, how the interests of the Guatemalan people are sacrificed for idealogical rigidity.
Happy 4th of July to all of you.
2 comments:
Hey Uwe,
Nice post. Sorry to hear you're getting a rough introduction, though.
Have you seen the movie "Watergate?" I believe it is there that the all-important line is spoken, "Follow the money." I gather this was never actually said during the investigations, but it works.
That's the problem with all these programs and organizations; they are following the money. Most aren't really committed to the program, they're just there for the jobs and the money. It's all downhill from there, my friend.
They all need to prove to the donors that they're doing the best job. When you don't have real results, which 99.44% probably don't, you have to put the others down to make yourself look good.
Why do I say most don't have real results? The local governments can't allow them to. The government is supposed to be doing the job, not some lousy foreign NGO, so they can't let them look good.
A cynical outlook, and one we have to work against, but it does play a role. Watch for it.
hey uwe. am highly enjoying reading your thoughts on NGO work. thank you for posting!!
your comments on development being messy and ideological ... that is a large part of the attraction for a lot of people to this field. the idea that they can do better, that they have the better plan. which i oppose since adding more possible solutions via diff avenues into the pot won't help. (at least in my op) there needs to be better streamlining and support of already existing ngos and solutions so that resources arent spread even thinner. o/w it's just a develoment industry rather than a development mission.
are you noticing any movement or creation of umbrella organizations? or have they just given up and wish to fight for the money and the fame of being the solution to the problem?
-p
Post a Comment