The following are two synopses of conversations I had on two different nights last week with two experienced development workers here in Guatemala. Neither of the conversations were held in a completely sober stage, so I apologize if the opinions voiced seem a bit overboard.
Conversation 1:
“Are you kidding me? You want to help the poor? Let me tell you something. This is all a big hoax. One of the biggest waste of resources you can imagine. Have you taken a look at the development facts of this country? Things are not getting better, they are getting worse despite all this money and all those NGOs that have come in to help develop this country, especially after the Civil War officially ended in 96. And no, it’s not only because the government is incapable or because the money was spent in the wrong places or for the wrong programs. It’s also because helping a society to overcome its problems is not our job. It can’t be our job, that’s preposterous. No matter if we talk about our previous efforts or the new wave of programs that try to give more ownership to the people. Have you ever witnessed an international NGO going into a rural community, talking about concepts like empowerment. It’s beautiful. People have never heard of these school book ideas, they don’t understand them. The idea of taking personal responsibility for your life is not familiar to them. God let me be born poor, so I will die poor, that’s how many of them feel. The level of conformity is incredibly high. And if you ask them what they need to better their lives, they always say yes. Do you need this? Yes. And that? Yes. So if you talk to me about participatory approaches, that might sound good in your development courses at school but the reality it is different. People are oftentimes not able to know what’s best for them. I hate to sound so harsh but it’s true. This idea of us coming here and making a prosperous and peaceful society out of a poor and ravaged country, such as Guatemala is just ridiculous. It in reality has the reverse effect. People think that we are here to do the work for them. Providing food, health, and education, bringing ideas, fighting for their rights, so on. And they will never be forced to take matters in their own hands, no matter how much ownership the organizations are trying put in their hands. The fact that outside NGOs enter in a community to help it “develop” is paternalism enough. Our idealism is hurting people, every day.”
Conversation 2:
“I am sick of all the criticism. We save lives every day, for Christ's sake. Do you have any idea what this country would look like if we weren’t here? Hundreds of thousands of people would be much worse off, they would not have health services, their kids would not go to school, they would not have a voice in the public sphere. Sure, we are not perfect. It’s complicated work. But we are doing our best, each single day. We are learning from our past and we are adapting our approaches constantly. People seem to think we just arrive here with some hidden agenda, or just come in and try something half-ass. But we are not. We are devoting our lives to helping these people. We look for funds, initiate projects, care for them, all because we see it as our responsibility, because nobody else is doing it. The government is failing horribly here, they are not able to do anything to help most of the population here. And as long as they don’t, we have to do it. As soon as there is a government that is able to guarantee the fundamental rights for its citizens, I am the first one to leave. And we are trying to help the government in this process. That’s why many of us have taken on a more political role. I can only laugh about all this talk about doing things wrong and making things worse. Yes, simple food distributions might not have been the most sustainable strategy but we still saved lives with it. How can you justify not helping people right now for the sake of helping future generations? How can I deny a mother help to feed her kids and instead tell her she has to grow her own crops or start her own business with a loan that I give her? Yes, this might be the more sustainable strategy in the long-run but my point is that we are still helping these people even if we give them a fish when they are starving and not tell them to learn how to fish first. When I read the news and hear people bashing our work, then I can only say that these people have no idea about the reality here. There is so much suffering, injustice, pain, exclusion, and discrimination that any help that even brings a little bit of alleviation is needed help. Yes, things might not be getting better fast but we are at least making sure that they are not getting worse.”
So here I stand now with my little friend thinking about where to go...
